Saw you down the aisle of a goodwill

Going through old vinyls for your record player

Always thought that it would be a big deal

Seeing you with someone new.

I used to make you laugh but never that loud

I thought it would be hard to know you're so damn happy

I haven't found it easy, but I'm good now

Seeing you, someone new.

The selfish side of me was hoping you'd be broken still

It's kind of bittersweet, I know, but this is how I feel.

It's like secondhand happiness

Never thought I'd smile for you again

But knowing it's for the best

I can lay my jealous heart to rest

It heals the pain, it heals the hurt

To see you find what you deserve

So I'll take what I can get

Secondhand happiness.

I hate talking about you in the past tense

Probably 'cause I always thought you'd be my future

But maybe in the future we could be friends

Some day soon

It's up to you.

The selfish side of me was hoping you'd be broken still

It's kind of bittersweet, I know, but this is how I feel.

It's like secondhand happiness

Never thought I'd smile for you again

But knowing it's for the best

I can lay my jealous heart to rest

It heals the pain, it heals the hurt

To see you find what you deserve

So I'll take what I can get

Secondhand happiness.

Secondhand happiness

Secondhand happiness.